Integrating Strategic Planning, Quality Management, and Needs Assessment
This chapter begins with a brief review of the terms and format of the book thus far. The first 6 chapters have focused on Strategic Planning (the "ends"). Chapter 7 then examines tactical planning (the "means" or the processes). Chapter 8 seeks to integrate all of the information presented, and it introduces the concept of quality management.
There comes a point in any educational planning initiative where it becomes necessary to scientifically evaluate ongoing progress. This is the job of quality management. Quality management is a process that initiated in the business world, but it has been heavily researched and analyzed, there are a variety of effective formats and "rules" for success, and QM has successfully migrated into educational settings.
Some of the most important aspects of corporate quality management that spill over into educational quality management are the need for dedicated teams, a focus on a whole system approach (no one is outside the feedback loop-i.e. politicians and board members held accountable too), and the integration of mega-planning (i.e. ideal vision) to create "quality management plus".
The final third of this chapter is almost wholly dedicated to explaining and advocating for QM+. The chief difference here (between it and regular QM) is the focus on social consciousness. Earlier chapters on mega-level planning have described the need for a truly idealized vision for the future; chapter 8 simply repeated these arguments in the context of it's usefulness to quality management.
Reading and Discussion Group for the book Educational Planning: Strategic, Tactical, and Operational by Roger Watters, Kathi Herman, Jerry Kaufman This is part of a course project for ITC 5720 at Appalachian State University.
Monday, October 15, 2012
Friday, October 12, 2012
Chapter 7
This chapter, Tactical Planning, focuses on taking a vision and determining what is needed in order to fulfill that vision. Planning must be able to find the most effective and efficient means of reaching that vision. Identifying advantages and disadvantages is also important as well as having an objective to meet The objective dictates the direction in which to go.
This chapter discusses many ways to address both quantitative and qualitative information. The tools discussed in this chapter can help assure useful planning.
One main obstacle addressed in this chapter is the budget. In many cases the budget is set before planning has been finished. This results in the plan being based only on monetary amounts and not much on needs.
Planning is important to address the needs in a school. Schools are always working to improve and strive for the vision that is constantly changing based on needs of the school/students.
This chapter discusses many ways to address both quantitative and qualitative information. The tools discussed in this chapter can help assure useful planning.
One main obstacle addressed in this chapter is the budget. In many cases the budget is set before planning has been finished. This results in the plan being based only on monetary amounts and not much on needs.
Planning is important to address the needs in a school. Schools are always working to improve and strive for the vision that is constantly changing based on needs of the school/students.
Sunday, October 7, 2012
Chapter 6
Chapter 6 discusses the SWOT method of analysis for planning for schools. Remember way back to Dr. Angel's class and the school improvement project? I really wish we could have read this before completing that project! It all makes sense to me now...
SWOT stands for: strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats.
A SWOT analysis is used to determine the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats that occur both within a school as well as external environment variables. After a SWOT analysis has been conducted, one can begin to identify strategies and tactics to assess problems within a school. Information that is gathered during a SWOT analysis should be valid and reliable. Possible types of information that may be gathered include demographic, political, social, financial, technological, and attitudinal. After this information is gathered, a SWOT table (exactly like the one we did in class) can be used to organize possible objectives to focus on. It is important to remember that these objectives should closely align to the ideal vision of the school/organization.
Once the SWOT analysis is complete and the objectives have been identified, mission and function analyses are used to determine what tools will be needed to meet the requirements of meeting the goals. The mission analysis is a broader analysis that simply identifies what is to be achieved, what criteria will be used to determined success, and the order of the events that needs to take place to meet the goal. The function analysis magnifies a smaller piece within the overall problem. Function analysis defines what needs to be completed in and in what order to achieve the mission objective.
All of the above mentioned analysis are integral parts of the system analysis. A system-analysis is results-oriented. The lowest level of system analysis is task analysis. Task analysis includes the identification and ordering of the steps to be taken (task inventory), and the description of requirements for successful job/task accomplishment (detailed task analysis). Ultimately, the results of task analysis should provide insight for continuous improvement and techniques to use to improve.
SWOT stands for: strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats.
A SWOT analysis is used to determine the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats that occur both within a school as well as external environment variables. After a SWOT analysis has been conducted, one can begin to identify strategies and tactics to assess problems within a school. Information that is gathered during a SWOT analysis should be valid and reliable. Possible types of information that may be gathered include demographic, political, social, financial, technological, and attitudinal. After this information is gathered, a SWOT table (exactly like the one we did in class) can be used to organize possible objectives to focus on. It is important to remember that these objectives should closely align to the ideal vision of the school/organization.
Once the SWOT analysis is complete and the objectives have been identified, mission and function analyses are used to determine what tools will be needed to meet the requirements of meeting the goals. The mission analysis is a broader analysis that simply identifies what is to be achieved, what criteria will be used to determined success, and the order of the events that needs to take place to meet the goal. The function analysis magnifies a smaller piece within the overall problem. Function analysis defines what needs to be completed in and in what order to achieve the mission objective.
All of the above mentioned analysis are integral parts of the system analysis. A system-analysis is results-oriented. The lowest level of system analysis is task analysis. Task analysis includes the identification and ordering of the steps to be taken (task inventory), and the description of requirements for successful job/task accomplishment (detailed task analysis). Ultimately, the results of task analysis should provide insight for continuous improvement and techniques to use to improve.
Saturday, September 29, 2012
Chapter 5
Needs Assessment
This chapter discusses the steps needed to conduct a needs assessment. A needs assessment is when you determine your gaps in results and then identify and prioritize your needs in order to come closer to the ideal vision. This is a reactive method to solving problems i an organization.
This chapter discusses the steps needed to conduct a needs assessment. A needs assessment is when you determine your gaps in results and then identify and prioritize your needs in order to come closer to the ideal vision. This is a reactive method to solving problems i an organization.
- Proactively decide to do a needs assessment to identify and justify problems.
- Identify the three needs assessment levels to be included and commit to the mega level as the starting place by completing a needs assessment matrix as seen on p84.
- Identify the needs assessment and planning partners (stakeholders) needed to proactively make the needed changes.
- Meet and discuss needs with planning partners. Explain exactly what is needed and get them to commit to participate.
- With planning partners, discuss the OEM and determine which level to aim for.
- Collect soft and hard data.
- Enter data on the matrix form until it feels complete and the mission objectives are clear p95. Be patient and work through frustration or disagreements. Keep the end goal in mind.
- Place needs in priority and settle all disagreements.
- List the problems that the team will work to resolve and get agreement from all partners.
Thursday, September 13, 2012
Chapter 4
A common theme for the entire book has certainly emerged by chapter four: effective strategic planning requires ends to be fully developed before means are discussed. A pop culture understanding of "the ends justify the means" section of Machiavelli's The Prince is not an entirely inaccurate or unuseful starting point for this type of thinking. Indeed, the entire planning structure advocated for in this text breaks down if shareholders attempt to select and mandate processes (techniques, educational strategies, technological tools, formats for lesson plans, etc) before they've discussed and agreed upon a shared vision and specific mission objectives.
For the purposes outlined by this text, mission statements are often synonymous with, and at the very least closely related to, ideal visions. Mission objectives, on the other hand have to meet much more elaborate criteria, because they are designed to move the planning process further towards completion. A full understanding of mission objectives requires three major pieces of information: how are high-quality mission objectives written, what are the two most common mistakes that planners make, and what does adequate measurability consist of?
How are high-quality mission objectives written?
The book outlines the ABCD format for mission objectives early on in the chapter. This same information is repeated four different times, in four slightly modified ways, throughout the rest of the pages of this section. This format/technique functions as an outline for individuals who are writing mission objectives. The laconic version of this outline states that all finalized mission objectives should thoroughly describe who, what, conditions, and criteria.
What are the two most common mistakes that mission planners make?
The failure to define and decide upon a high quality mission objective usually occurs in one of two ways (note these are "how" issues, not "why" issues). First, mission planners get distracted by means and forget to focus on ends. Means cannot be mission objectives; they are mutually exclusive concepts at this stage of the planning process. Second, mission planners define objectives that are two broad. This is the classical difference between a mission statement and a mission objective--objectives can be adequately measured.
What does adequate measurability consist of?
The concepts of nominal, ordinal, interval, and ratio measurements help planners to decide whether or not their mission objectives are truly objective. These four types of measurement are described in detail in the chapter, but it's most important to remember that good mission objectives have either interval or ratio measurability. I find the following quote immensely valuable in this particular discussion, "But pretending that some things are not measurable, or 'intangible,' avoids reality and places important--and often very humanistic--results and achievements in question" (p. 59).
For the purposes outlined by this text, mission statements are often synonymous with, and at the very least closely related to, ideal visions. Mission objectives, on the other hand have to meet much more elaborate criteria, because they are designed to move the planning process further towards completion. A full understanding of mission objectives requires three major pieces of information: how are high-quality mission objectives written, what are the two most common mistakes that planners make, and what does adequate measurability consist of?
How are high-quality mission objectives written?
The book outlines the ABCD format for mission objectives early on in the chapter. This same information is repeated four different times, in four slightly modified ways, throughout the rest of the pages of this section. This format/technique functions as an outline for individuals who are writing mission objectives. The laconic version of this outline states that all finalized mission objectives should thoroughly describe who, what, conditions, and criteria.
What are the two most common mistakes that mission planners make?
The failure to define and decide upon a high quality mission objective usually occurs in one of two ways (note these are "how" issues, not "why" issues). First, mission planners get distracted by means and forget to focus on ends. Means cannot be mission objectives; they are mutually exclusive concepts at this stage of the planning process. Second, mission planners define objectives that are two broad. This is the classical difference between a mission statement and a mission objective--objectives can be adequately measured.
What does adequate measurability consist of?
The concepts of nominal, ordinal, interval, and ratio measurements help planners to decide whether or not their mission objectives are truly objective. These four types of measurement are described in detail in the chapter, but it's most important to remember that good mission objectives have either interval or ratio measurability. I find the following quote immensely valuable in this particular discussion, "But pretending that some things are not measurable, or 'intangible,' avoids reality and places important--and often very humanistic--results and achievements in question" (p. 59).
Monday, September 10, 2012
Chapter 3-Strategic Planning: Starts with the Ideal Vision
Chapter 3 discusses the importance of developing an ideal vision. This is important in anything that you do. An ideal vision is like having a long-term, "perfect" goal. An ideal vision doesn't just pop into your mind. It takes lots of planning and discussion to reach it.
The first step in developing an ideal vsion is to "identify, define, and plan" (p.39) what is intended for the future. There must a group of "planning partners" that work together. These partners are representatives from all areas involved in the outcome. The second step is to identify measureable objectives. These obectives must be clearly written and easily understood. According to the authors, the third step in creating an ideal vision is to focus on the results, not the method in which it will be obtained. Lastly, being positive and not negative is the fourth step toward the ideal vision. The ideal vision is a result of the planning of many individuals that come together as one to create the "dream".
When thinking of an ideal vision, one must ponder the question, In what kind of world do we want our children and grandchildren to live? Having put it that way, strategic planning is a must in order to set high standards to develop an ideal vision. The authors state that even though we may never meet that standard in our lifetime, we must always have a goal in which to strive.
We realize it will take some time as we move toward the goal. This reminds me of how our teaching standards are changing. We are now teaching the common core. We cannot expect our students to completely change over night or over the course of one year. We take steps toward the goals for continued improvement. Change will occur over a period of time. As our students in the lower grades become familiar with the common core processes, over time upper grades will see differences in the learning that is taking place. It is a building process, and we will continue to rise to the top if we set our ideal vision at the top.
The first step in developing an ideal vsion is to "identify, define, and plan" (p.39) what is intended for the future. There must a group of "planning partners" that work together. These partners are representatives from all areas involved in the outcome. The second step is to identify measureable objectives. These obectives must be clearly written and easily understood. According to the authors, the third step in creating an ideal vision is to focus on the results, not the method in which it will be obtained. Lastly, being positive and not negative is the fourth step toward the ideal vision. The ideal vision is a result of the planning of many individuals that come together as one to create the "dream".
When thinking of an ideal vision, one must ponder the question, In what kind of world do we want our children and grandchildren to live? Having put it that way, strategic planning is a must in order to set high standards to develop an ideal vision. The authors state that even though we may never meet that standard in our lifetime, we must always have a goal in which to strive.
We realize it will take some time as we move toward the goal. This reminds me of how our teaching standards are changing. We are now teaching the common core. We cannot expect our students to completely change over night or over the course of one year. We take steps toward the goals for continued improvement. Change will occur over a period of time. As our students in the lower grades become familiar with the common core processes, over time upper grades will see differences in the learning that is taking place. It is a building process, and we will continue to rise to the top if we set our ideal vision at the top.
Saturday, September 8, 2012
Chapter 2
Chapter 2- Mega-Planning: A New and Practical Paradigm
In chapter 2, the authors write about a new way to plan for school success. This chapter made a lot of sense to me as a teacher working during a time of change in terms of new curriculum (with the Common Core) and new administrators at my school.
Too often I have heard teachers, administrators and county office employees say "we need __________". Or, "if we had __________, we could do ____________". Rarely, if ever, do I hear about the "big picture" and what is the ultimate goal of the school system. Do we really need all of this "stuff" to be successful if we don't have a plan for where we want to go?
The authors state that the "ends" or goals for a school need to be determined before the "means" are created. Means are ways to deliver "ends". These are resources, money, people, salary increases, etc. It seems like everyone is asking or wanting something these days but has no clear path drawn for how these "means" will really impact the school, school system and ultimately society, as a whole.
Rarely do I hear about goals for my school that will promote growth in the school system or society as one entity. Our school seems to be focused on raising test scores and getting back our title as a "School of Excellence". But what does a title as a "School of Excellence" do for the future of our students and society as a whole? Nothing. Titles do not impact the future.
This chapter defines the need for "mega planning". A "mega" beneficiary would include the entire community and society. The plan would focus primarily on the current and future good of society. Instead of focusing on individuals and small groups (micro) or the school/school system (macro) separately, the authors of this chapter state that it is necessary to link educational efforts, organizational results and societal payoffs to integrate micro and macro into a mega plan. A good educational planning template to use in this approach is the OEM framework (Organizational Elements Model). This framework identifies a result for each of the three types of levels: mega, micro and macro.
In order for schools across the state (and possibly the nation) to contribute to society and the future, there needs to be an established "common good" with shared purposes and goals that everyone can contribute to in some way. We need to establish what our goals are to help our students be successful in their adult lives. We also need to map out what our society is going to require from our population in the future to thrive. We have to do more than think about the future, we have to plan for it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)