A common theme for the entire book has certainly emerged by chapter four: effective strategic planning requires ends to be fully developed before means are discussed. A pop culture understanding of "the ends justify the means" section of Machiavelli's The Prince is not an entirely inaccurate or unuseful starting point for this type of thinking. Indeed, the entire planning structure advocated for in this text breaks down if shareholders attempt to select and mandate processes (techniques, educational strategies, technological tools, formats for lesson plans, etc) before they've discussed and agreed upon a shared vision and specific mission objectives.
For the purposes outlined by this text, mission statements are often synonymous with, and at the very least closely related to, ideal visions. Mission objectives, on the other hand have to meet much more elaborate criteria, because they are designed to move the planning process further towards completion. A full understanding of mission objectives requires three major pieces of information: how are high-quality mission objectives written, what are the two most common mistakes that planners make, and what does adequate measurability consist of?
How are high-quality mission objectives written?
The book outlines the ABCD format for mission objectives early on in the chapter. This same information is repeated four different times, in four slightly modified ways, throughout the rest of the pages of this section. This format/technique functions as an outline for individuals who are writing mission objectives. The laconic version of this outline states that all finalized mission objectives should thoroughly describe who, what, conditions, and criteria.
What are the two most common mistakes that mission planners make?
The failure to define and decide upon a high quality mission objective usually occurs in one of two ways (note these are "how" issues, not "why" issues). First, mission planners get distracted by means and forget to focus on ends. Means cannot be mission objectives; they are mutually exclusive concepts at this stage of the planning process. Second, mission planners define objectives that are two broad. This is the classical difference between a mission statement and a mission objective--objectives can be adequately measured.
What does adequate measurability consist of?
The concepts of nominal, ordinal, interval, and ratio measurements help planners to decide whether or not their mission objectives are truly objective. These four types of measurement are described in detail in the chapter, but it's most important to remember that good mission objectives have either interval or ratio measurability. I find the following quote immensely valuable in this particular discussion, "But pretending that some things are not measurable, or 'intangible,' avoids reality and places important--and often very humanistic--results and achievements in question" (p. 59).
I agree that when writing objectives one must look at the who, the what, the conditions, and the criteria.
ReplyDeleteWhen planning for technology, there must be long-range goals and planning that must be in place in order to make improvements. The plan would include who the technology would help, what they were going to do, the conditions needed in order for it to work, and the criteria in deciding the outcome.
I also agree that the ends must be identified before the means are created. As a teacher, I'm not sure that we (as teachers) are always aware of what specifically the ends are when these plans/objectives are created at the county/state level. Often times, I feel like we are required to carry out the means to meet the ends, but we aren't always informed as to what exactly the ends are. Sure, we might have a general idea, like "preparing our students to live in a globally competitive world" or to "ensure every child can read by the time they graduate"...but as for the specifics, we are often left in the dark. There needs to be some way for these ends to be specifically shared with teachers. I suppose the county Technology Plan outlines these "ends"...but it took a lot of "digging around" on the county website to even find the plan. Why are these not more easily accessible to the public?
ReplyDeleteWell said, Katherine.
ReplyDeleteI think that part of the issue is that the general public has slowly become less involved in their children's schools over time. For example, my school has to beg parents to be on the PTO committee. At this point, we have three members and in previous years our school has had to beg parents to take part so that it had any members at all. People expect our school systems to run efficiently without having to lift a finger to make it do so. Our lives are more busy now than in decades past and knowing what the school is doing is on the back burner. Since the community does not demand this information, schools have no accountability to readily provide it.
ReplyDelete