In chapter 2, the authors write about a new way to plan for school success. This chapter made a lot of sense to me as a teacher working during a time of change in terms of new curriculum (with the Common Core) and new administrators at my school.
Too often I have heard teachers, administrators and county office employees say "we need __________". Or, "if we had __________, we could do ____________". Rarely, if ever, do I hear about the "big picture" and what is the ultimate goal of the school system. Do we really need all of this "stuff" to be successful if we don't have a plan for where we want to go?
The authors state that the "ends" or goals for a school need to be determined before the "means" are created. Means are ways to deliver "ends". These are resources, money, people, salary increases, etc. It seems like everyone is asking or wanting something these days but has no clear path drawn for how these "means" will really impact the school, school system and ultimately society, as a whole.
Rarely do I hear about goals for my school that will promote growth in the school system or society as one entity. Our school seems to be focused on raising test scores and getting back our title as a "School of Excellence". But what does a title as a "School of Excellence" do for the future of our students and society as a whole? Nothing. Titles do not impact the future.
This chapter defines the need for "mega planning". A "mega" beneficiary would include the entire community and society. The plan would focus primarily on the current and future good of society. Instead of focusing on individuals and small groups (micro) or the school/school system (macro) separately, the authors of this chapter state that it is necessary to link educational efforts, organizational results and societal payoffs to integrate micro and macro into a mega plan. A good educational planning template to use in this approach is the OEM framework (Organizational Elements Model). This framework identifies a result for each of the three types of levels: mega, micro and macro.
In order for schools across the state (and possibly the nation) to contribute to society and the future, there needs to be an established "common good" with shared purposes and goals that everyone can contribute to in some way. We need to establish what our goals are to help our students be successful in their adult lives. We also need to map out what our society is going to require from our population in the future to thrive. We have to do more than think about the future, we have to plan for it.
I find it interesting that I too hear about all the technology we NEED in order to "teach the way they want us to teach". Last year, every teacher received IPads at my school. This was intended for use with the students. Unfortunately, too many teachers are using it for personal use and not for student learning.
ReplyDeleteWhile reading this chapter, I reflected back to the district and state technology plans. Honestly, I had never looked in detail at either plan-until the past week. If teachers see the "mega" plan, they may be more inclined to allow the students more discovery using the technology we do have. Teachers will also see the district is working toward state goals as funds permit. We have a national, state, and district plan in progress. We always have technology included in our school improvement plan; perhaps a more detailed plan for each specific school would help the teachers be more appreciative and accepting of what our administrators are trying to do to increase student learning.
This week, I had a very frustrating experience. When looking at what our students need to be able to contribute to our future society, it seems like we are really failing out kids. A group of 5th grade students spent 45 minutes researching a science topic. Many of them had no idea how to follow links I carefully selected nor could they read at a level that would allow them to understand the information that was easily a 5th grade level. When it came to "note taking" skills. Many students just copied words from the screen even though they did not understand what they said. They also did not take the time to really read the information so that they could understand it. When I see this, I worry that we are not implementing the types of lessons that we need to in order to prepare our students. My question is, why are they not able to complete such a simple task?
ReplyDeleteIn my English classroom, at least, I feel like the common core initiative was originally intended to be a mega-planning, purpose-oriented solution. The information that I read at the national and even the state level about the new standards had me optimistic that our educational leaders were actually beginning to consider a more big picture view of the educational system. Now, I'm not so sure. The freedom built into the original system seems to be getting systematically forced out to make room for more and more process-oriented activities.
ReplyDeleteRhonda, we had a similar "strategic misuse of technology" problem at my school a couple of years ago when the district spent hundreds of thousands of dollars giving almost every teacher a SmartBoard. Subsequently, we were given zero training, and no one even took the time to describe a general vision for how we were supposed to demonstrate the effective use of the new technology. We were told the equivalent of, "when you're being observed, you should make sure you're seen using this new stuff." Naturally, teacher energy and enthusiasm that could have been harnessed and directed in a productive way was instead squandered, and cynicism about the new tools runs rampant to this day.
Julianne, I feel your pain here, and I sympathize. I recently assigned my 10th graders a reading and vocabulary level placement test, so that I could better differentiate my assignments for them. Most of my honors(!) class is apparently reading at around a 6th grade level (though their vocabulary scores are much closer to grade level), and my CP class averaged about a 4th grade reading level and a 5th grade vocabulary. I can't help but think, when these kids graduate in a few years we will be flooding society with another wave of functionally literate non-readers. And people who don't read...well it doesn't bode well. How far have our educational priorities had to shift to get to the point where this is considered an acceptable outcome as long as they can pass a few multiple choice tests? ...sigh